The moments fans replayed most: the 'Most replayed' peaks of 12 music videos

Above the progress bar of a YouTube video floats a hill-shaped graph marking the 'Most replayed' parts. The more people went back to a stretch, the higher it rises. The height is relative, with the highest point in the video set to 1, so it can't tell you how many times anything was watched. The start of a video plays every time it's opened, so it usually comes out high. On October 7, we pulled this graph from 42 official videos of songs on the Bugs weekly chart. In 26 of them, another spot rose higher than the opening. We picked twelve and matched the picture and lyrics to see what happens at that peak. Times follow the videos below, and the graphs can shift a little over time.

At a glance

Video	Most replayed stretch	What's on screen
SOYEON 'I'm gonna TOESA'	3:23–3:25	The grandmother turns back into SOYEON
KiiiKiii 'Pop Off Pop Off'	0:35–0:37	From a white cliff into the sea
Hwasa 'Good Goodbye'	2:22–2:24	Beside a piano under a tree
ALLDAY PROJECT 'CRASH'	1:45–1:47	Dancing on a rainy night road
ATEEZ 'BAD'	2:55–2:57	A courtroom turns into a dance floor
BIGBANG 'BiiiG'	2:21–2:23	A stage with a car hanging above it
aespa 'LEMONADE'	1:30–1:32	A shadow before a yellow circle
I.O.I 'Suddenly'	2:33–2:35	The members lined up before a mint wall
NMIXX 'Blue Valentine'	2:30–2:32	The chorus dance to 'If this love is over'
Hearts2Hearts 'Lemon Tang'	0:58–1:00	'Lemon ta-ta-tang'
CORTIS 'REDRED'	0:41–0:43	'that's red-red'
ILLIT 'NOT CUTE ANYMORE'	0:47–0:48	Right after 'I'm not cute anymore'

Moments where the story flips

3:23 · SOYEON 'I'm gonna TOESA' (퇴사할게여)

Around the last verse, a grandmother in a white sleeveless top smiles at the camera in the middle of a street. From 3:24, for a little over two seconds, the wrinkles lift and the face turns back into SOYEON's. Those two seconds are the highest point of the graph in the whole video. The scene of SOYEON as a grandmother also came up in our October 9 Hidden Details. Apple Music

0:35 · KiiiKiii 'Pop Off Pop Off'

At 0:35 a computer settings window flashes past, and at 0:36 a member dives from a white rock cliff into the blue sea. Right after, the five members dance on top of that white cliff. The video is short, at 2:23, and the spot where the replays pile up comes just 36 seconds in. Apple Music

2:22 · Hwasa 'Good Goodbye'

A piano stands on a nighttime lawn under a tree wrapped in string lights. Hwasa, in a white dress, smiles at a partner in a tuxedo, and the two face each other beside the piano. Of the twelve, this video has the most views (over 189 million as of October 7). Apple Music

Moments when the dancing draws the replays

1:45 · ALLDAY PROJECT 'CRASH'

The members dance on a rainy night road lit by car headlights. Just before, at 1:43.6, a column of water shoots up and the sound stops for 0.4 seconds. That silence is covered in our October 3 Hidden Details. The replays pile up not on the silence but on the dance in the rain that follows. Apple Music

2:55 · ATEEZ 'BAD'

The video's story runs from a wedding to a courtroom. At 2:55 that courtroom turns into a dance floor. Dancers in polka-dot dresses and black hats dance along the gallery railing, and a member in a gold jacket steps toward the camera. Other scenes from the video are in our October 13 Hidden Details. Apple Music

2:21 · BIGBANG 'BiiiG'

On a stage with a car hanging in the air, the members come out in front of the dancers and dance. The graph rises to almost the same height at two spots, 2:21 and 3:02. The scene where '붉은 노을' (red sunset) becomes '푸른 노을' (blue sunset) is in our October 14 Hidden Details. Apple Music

1:30 · aespa 'LEMONADE'

At 1:30 a member in orange stockings walks through the diner, and at 1:31, in front of a round yellow light, a figure's shadow spreads both arms and dances. It pairs well with our October 17 Hidden Details, which pinpoints where the backing stops on 'Wait'. Apple Music

2:33 · I.O.I 'Suddenly' (갑자기)

The members stand in a row in front of a mint-colored wall, and one by one they step forward to dance. The lyrics run from '우리 추억들' ("our memories") to '자꾸만 아른거리잖아' ("they keep flickering before my eyes"). Apple Music

2:30 · NMIXX 'Blue Valentine'

This is where the final chorus, 'If this love is over', starts again. The members dance in a sun-drenched front yard. The graph is more than five times higher here than at the opening scene. Apple Music

Songs whose peak is a single line

0:58 · Hearts2Hearts 'Lemon Tang'

This is where 'Lemon ta-ta-tang' arrives at 0:58, right after '지금부터' ("from now on"). The members, in sailor uniforms, dance together on a seaside festival street. Apple Music

0:41 · CORTIS 'REDRED'

This is where 'that's red-red' repeats, after '신호등 바뀌었어 green green' ("the light changed, green green"). The members, walking under an overpass, come up to the camera. The story of its final 40 seconds is in our September 22 article. Apple Music

0:47 · ILLIT 'NOT CUTE ANYMORE'

Right after 'I'm not cute anymore' is sung at 0:44, the group choreography begins under blue lights. In this video, the replays pile up most not on the moment the title is sung but on the dance right after it. Apple Music